Budgeting Without Linking Your Bank
Yes, you can run a real budget without ever connecting your bank account. You enter a few amounts yourself, once, and track a single number from there. No account logins, no aggregator between you and your bank, no bank credentials sitting in anyone's database.
Most budgeting apps link your accounts by default. Skipping that is a real choice with real reasons behind it, and the method that replaces it stands on its own. Here's how it works.
Why skip the bank link
A few reasons people would rather not hand an app their bank login:
- Every account you connect is one more place your credentials and transaction data live. If that app has a breach, your financial life is in it.
- A linked app can see all of it: every purchase, every deposit, every place you shop. That's a lot to hand over in exchange for a spending number.
- With free apps, the watching is the business. Mint made its money by tracking your spending and recommending financial products it earned a cut on. Free, because the data was the point.
Linking is still a reasonable choice. It's worth knowing what's on both sides before you make it.
What linking gets you
Linking does real work. It pulls in your transactions automatically, keeps your balances current, and powers the deep tracking some apps are built around. Monarch, the tool a lot of Mint users moved to, works this way. Connect your accounts and it tracks your investments, your net worth, and your whole cash flow in one place. Monarch also charges a subscription instead of selling your data, which is a cleaner deal than the free-but-watched model.
So if that depth is what you're after, linking is the cost of it, and it's a fair one. If you want to see the no-link approach next to Monarch and the others, here's the comparison.
The no-link method
Here's the version that never touches your bank.
You enter amounts, not credentials. Your income, your fixed costs, and what you set aside each month for the bills that don't come monthly. That's a handful of numbers, typed once, and they barely move month to month, so there's no daily upkeep. From them you get your One Number: what you have left unspent this month. (The full walkthrough shows the subtraction with real figures.)
The reason this works without transaction tracking is that the method doesn't need it. You put your discretionary spending on one card and check that card's balance against your One Number. The balance is your live gauge, so nothing has to watch your purchases to tell you where you stand. You can see it yourself, on the card already in your pocket.
What you give up
There's a real tradeoff. Because you're not linked, nothing auto-fills your numbers or imports a history of what you've spent. If you want an app that watches your transactions and sorts them into categories for you, a link-based tool is the one to get, and that's a reasonable thing to want.
The no-link method skips that on purpose. The one-card gauge does the same job, telling you what's left, without an app sitting inside your accounts. You trade automatic tracking for keeping your bank to yourself. For a lot of people that's an easy trade.
See your number
You can work your One Number out on paper, or put your income, fixed costs, and set-asides into our calculator and get it in about a minute. It runs entirely in your browser, so nothing you type leaves your device.
When you want it to keep running, the app holds your number month to month and gives you the one figure to check your card against. Personal is $9 / month, with a 14-day trial and no card to start. It never asks for a bank login, because it never needs one.
Not ready for either? Join the list and follow along. No spam, and we never ask for your bank login.